Blockazine

‘Elsinore’ review: Andrew Scott’s Hamlet outshines the film around him

In a review published on November 20, 2026, NPR praised Andrew Scott’s performance in Elsinore while arguing that the film too often pushes for emotions its lead actor can convey without help.

Scott plays Scottish actor Ian Charleson, who is performing Hamlet at Britain’s National Theatre while dying of AIDS. The film is set in 1989. For NPR’s reviewer, one of its most affecting moments is a quiet hospital-room close-up: Ian composes himself before visitors arrive, rehearsing the reassuring smile he intends to give them.

The review finds the film strongest when director Simon Stone stays with the practical routines of Ian’s life—medical appointments, rehearsals, memorising lines and fight choreography. It also praises the dark humour among Ian’s friends. But it argues that Stefan Gregory’s insistent score, repeated familiar passages from Hamlet and shots of tearful audience members overstate what Scott’s performance has already made clear.

NPR’s reviewer also questions a scene in which Ian persuades activist and filmmaker Derek Jarman, played by David Dawson, to accept his decision not to come out. Olivia Colman appears as Ian’s doctor. The review’s verdict is admiring of Scott, but frustrated that Elsinore does not more consistently trust him—or its audience.

Further reading